![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
alexandraerinSo, if you go to Amazon.com and you do a search for "homosexuality", the number one result right now is that much-loved family classic A Parent's Guide to Preventing Homosexuality. The search result orders are based on sales ranks, so clearly this is the most popular book about homosexuality, right?
Either that or there's some kind of horrendous double-standard in play where books dealing with the topic in a positive or even neutral light are being suppressed or stricken from the rankings while garbage like this is being left in for the world to see.
But that couldn't be it, could it?
*nervous laughter*
The AP has published a piece calling it a "glitch", but the blogosphere has a different name for it: Amazon Fail. Do a Google search for that and you'll find all kinds of stuff, including summaries of what was removed (books about queer folk, books by queer folk, books about feminism, romance involving GLBT characters, autobiographies, etc.) All supposedly removed for being "adult".
Glitch? They may not have fully scoped out the consequences of this policy, but this wasn't a computer zigging where it should have zagged... books that have been ranked and listed forever were suddenly pulled, in a manner that is both sweeping and haphazard... so there had to have been human eyes and human hands involved in these removals. Amazon's responses to individual inquiries that have been posted around hasn't mentioned any glitch... they claim that these books are being removed from the rankings because they're adults. Even the "glitch" story mentions that an earlier individual case that this mass removal mirrors.
Heather Has Two Mommies is now an "adult" book. If you do a search for it, the only thing that comes up is a pre-order for an anniversary special edition that's not out yet. If that wasn't there, the number one result would be a book addressing the "controversy" of the book's very existence. You can still find the original book on the site if you click around (for instance, there are links to it from the special edition's page), but you'll note it doesn't list a sales rank for it. That's Amazon's method of making sure a product doesn't show up when you type it in the box at the top. Yes. Even if you're looking for that specific title. Granted there are parents out there who don't want their children reading it, but at the age the book is aimed at, the kid's not likely to be shopping on Amazon by themselves. Amazon has taken it upon themselves to decide the matter for all parents.
OH! While I was writing that paragraph, the special edition disappeared from the rank. The controversy write-up is now number one. That's a pretty dedicated glitch, Amazon! Other, less well-known gay parent books show up in the search results for that exact title, presumably because they're compared to it... this is what I meant by haphazard.
And you know what's really stupid about it? Do a search for "butt plug". You'd think a concentrated effort to screen for adult material would have taken care of things that only exist to serve adult purposes...
What can you do? Complain to Amazon. Post about this in your blog or on your twitter. Use the words "amazon fail" (and the Twitter hash tag "#amazonfail".) These things are tracked and trended, and Amazon is one of the venerable old dotcoms. If they don't pay attention to this shit, I don't know who does.
Either that or there's some kind of horrendous double-standard in play where books dealing with the topic in a positive or even neutral light are being suppressed or stricken from the rankings while garbage like this is being left in for the world to see.
But that couldn't be it, could it?
*nervous laughter*
The AP has published a piece calling it a "glitch", but the blogosphere has a different name for it: Amazon Fail. Do a Google search for that and you'll find all kinds of stuff, including summaries of what was removed (books about queer folk, books by queer folk, books about feminism, romance involving GLBT characters, autobiographies, etc.) All supposedly removed for being "adult".
Glitch? They may not have fully scoped out the consequences of this policy, but this wasn't a computer zigging where it should have zagged... books that have been ranked and listed forever were suddenly pulled, in a manner that is both sweeping and haphazard... so there had to have been human eyes and human hands involved in these removals. Amazon's responses to individual inquiries that have been posted around hasn't mentioned any glitch... they claim that these books are being removed from the rankings because they're adults. Even the "glitch" story mentions that an earlier individual case that this mass removal mirrors.
Heather Has Two Mommies is now an "adult" book. If you do a search for it, the only thing that comes up is a pre-order for an anniversary special edition that's not out yet. If that wasn't there, the number one result would be a book addressing the "controversy" of the book's very existence. You can still find the original book on the site if you click around (for instance, there are links to it from the special edition's page), but you'll note it doesn't list a sales rank for it. That's Amazon's method of making sure a product doesn't show up when you type it in the box at the top. Yes. Even if you're looking for that specific title. Granted there are parents out there who don't want their children reading it, but at the age the book is aimed at, the kid's not likely to be shopping on Amazon by themselves. Amazon has taken it upon themselves to decide the matter for all parents.
OH! While I was writing that paragraph, the special edition disappeared from the rank. The controversy write-up is now number one. That's a pretty dedicated glitch, Amazon! Other, less well-known gay parent books show up in the search results for that exact title, presumably because they're compared to it... this is what I meant by haphazard.
And you know what's really stupid about it? Do a search for "butt plug". You'd think a concentrated effort to screen for adult material would have taken care of things that only exist to serve adult purposes...
What can you do? Complain to Amazon. Post about this in your blog or on your twitter. Use the words "amazon fail" (and the Twitter hash tag "#amazonfail".) These things are tracked and trended, and Amazon is one of the venerable old dotcoms. If they don't pay attention to this shit, I don't know who does.
![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png){kind=small}
no subject
on 2009-04-13 09:20 am (UTC)Works like this:
Troll sees something that isn't quite right, like Amazon's "Adult" content.
Troll thinks "This will be lots of lulz to mess with this."
Media complains that Amazon is banning gay content.
Amazon comes back next week and says "Now the button will just flag it for us to look at and see if it's Adult Content."
Trolls laugh.
???
Profit.
Skip step 3, and Amazon has no reason to change anything. Sure, it keeps the trolls away from the lulz, and that make keep them from breeding. Maybe they eat lulz, I don't know.
What is also amusing, and something that should be considered by anyone upset that Amazon might possibly be censoring anything, is the thought that the queer trolls might be able to take this further than Amazon. Imagine a trolling group countering every move by the real anti-gay trolls; the ones that send letters to restaurants or commercials who happen to have a known gay actor walking in the background or, heaven forbid, using the product being sold. Picture those corporations being flooded with letters every time they dare to use a straight actor, how dare they insult the queer community like that.
It's a lovely picture.